|
| When you divide, you rule |
 |
 |
Rattan Chugh
ExpressMoney
It’s not enough to spread your investment portfolio across various asset classes. How you do it matters equally, if not more
In a 2005 survey of savings preferences of Indian investors done by the ministry of finance, 90 per cent of the 41,040 households interviewed across a cross-section of age, gender, geographical, literacy and income profiles proclaimed real estate as the safest of asset classes. Safer than government-guaranteed instruments. Safer than bank deposits insured by the government till a limit. |
| |
Surprising, but true. It’s a perception grounded not in a deep understanding of the world of investments, but in the tangible nature of land or house -- unlike a financial instrument, you can see and feel it. It gives a feeling of security and shapes the classic Indian investor’s response, “my first investment should be a house”.
Vishal Sharma, a resident of Gurgaon and a partner in an upcoming advertising agency, is a firm believer in real estate as an investment. Real estate is safer. You can see your assets on the ground,” he says. About 70 per cent of his portfolio is invested in real estate, and that doesn’t even include the house he, wife Sarika and kids Purusharth (6 years) and Vaidehi (4 years) live in. |
| |
| The Real Picture |
| |
Diversification is the key to managing portfolio risk. It works at two levels. One, your wealth should be allocated optimally across various asset classes. Two, in each asset class, you should have invested in a suitable number of instruments. This helps reduce the risk of concentration in a particular asset class, industry or security. If one asset class is doing badly, others can make up for it.
In that context, how you diversify also becomes important. Your investments should show a low degree of correlation with each other, or you might get caught in extremes. A financial advisor can review your portfolio and measure how closely the value of your individual investments moves together over time. If the value of all your investments tends to move in the same direction, you own a high-risk portfolio. Vishal’s portfolio, most of which is in real estate, inhabits that extreme, as it runs the risk from a meltdown in the property market.
|
 There are other problems too with a high real estate holding. The industry is not transparent. Investments are not liquid as say shares and mutual funds, and transaction costs are higher. Typically, the ticket size of such investments runs into many lakh, which limits exit options. If, for instance, you needed Rs 1 lakh for an emergency, you will need to sell a house or a piece of land that is worth a multiple of that. When you sell, you will have to pay capital gains tax on your entire sales proceeds, in addition to incurring transaction costs. Since you need only Rs 1 lakh, you will need to reinvest the balance, which means incurring transaction costs all over again. |
| |
| Keeping the Balance |
| |
For those reasons, Vishal needs to lighten up on his real estate holding, in favour of equity and debt. Ironically, he came to real estate from those very asset classes, as he saw greater appreciation potential there. Says Vishal:” The stock market is unpredictable. I booked profits through the bull run, and invested in real estate.” That pattern of investing typifies Vishal’s comfortable equation with money. “Money is a tool that provides you freedom, and that’s it,” he says.
Vishal, who resolved to become financially independent in his growing years after losing his father early, has built financial security for the family and bought insurance to shield them from potential disasters. From his first salary, he invested in equity and got himself term insurance. Today, he has assets across equity, debt and real estate. He has systematic investment plans in diversified equity funds to cover his goals of children’s education and retirement. The key for Vishal to strengthen that foundation is to monitor and rebalance his portfolio.
Such an exercise involves reviewing your portfolio performance and asset allocation once every three months. Mind you, I’m not recommending action every three months, as that will breed impulsive behaviour and bleed you in transaction costs and taxes.
I’m only recommending a three-month review. It will help you track performance of your holdings: which funds are doing well and which aren’t compared to the benchmarks, whether there has been an extraordinary increase in the share of a particular asset class. Such a periodicity will give you more data points and a greater understanding of your investments, which will give you clarity on when and how to rebalance. I suggest you rebalance your investments once a year.
Vishal, for instance, should review his risk and return profile, and develop an appropriate portfolio plan. He sees himself as a long-term investor, which makes it all the more important for him to have a strategy and be reasonably diversified.
Vishal should liquidate one of his real estate investments before the next instalment is due, and reinvest in other asset classes. Since Vishal is still in the accumulation stage of his life, he can partly rebalance his portfolio by making future investments in equities-related assets. Equities have historically given superior returns over a long period of time and also the stock markets tend to capture the overall growth in the economy. To start with, Vishal should lower his real estate holding from 70 per cent to 50 per cent, and subsequently to 30 per cent. As Benjamin Graham once said, “There are those who make money and there are those who keep it.” |
| |
Vishal Sharma, a partner in an ad agency, has built a good money foundation for his family: own house, essential insurance covers, equity-based investment plans for kids education, a healthy portfolio across asset classes. However, his portfolio is skewed towards real estate-70 per cent share. “Real estate is safer. You can see your assets on the ground,” he says. To make the diversification in his portfolio more meaningful, he needs to lighten up on real estate. |
|
| |
| |
|
|
| |
| Home |
| |
|